CarSpecsHQ

255/45R19 vs 235/50R19

235/50R19 is a safe swap for 255/45R19 by the usual ±3% rule: the diameter differs by +0.77%.

19" rim
255/45R19 28.04" · 235/50R19 28.25" · drawn to scale

Side by side

255/45R19235/50R19Difference
Overall diameter28.04"28.25"+0.22" (+0.77%)
Section width255 mm235 mm-20 mm
Sidewall4.52"4.63"+0.11"
Rim19"19"same
Circumference88.1"88.8"+0.7"
Revs per mile719714-6
Ride height——+0.11"
Speedometer reads 60 mph60.060.5+0.5 mph

Speedometer and odometer

020406080100120 reads 60 · actual 60.5 mph

With 235/50R19 on a car calibrated for 255/45R19, the speedometer reads 59.5 mph when you're really doing 60, and the odometer under-counts by 0.8%.

Speedo showsActual speed
30 mph30.2 mph
45 mph45.3 mph
60 mph60.5 mph
70 mph70.5 mph
80 mph80.6 mph

Other sizes close to 255/45R19

Questions

Can I replace 255/45R19 with 235/50R19?

235/50R19 is a safe swap for 255/45R19 by the usual ±3% rule: the diameter differs by +0.77%.

What's the difference between 255/45R19 and 235/50R19?

235/50R19 is 0.22" taller and 20 mm narrower; the sidewall is +0.11". At an indicated 60 mph you'd actually be doing 60.5 mph.

Will 235/50R19 fit on 255/45R19 wheels?

Both use a 19" rim, so the wheel diameter matches; check the wheel's width range for a 235 mm tire and the fender clearance.